Your IP has been blocked. Please perform the action below to regain access.
75.126.130.58-
Customer Reviews
Average Rating:
-
Best Bohème
This is one of the best opera recordings ever produced. For more than a decade, Freni-Pavarotti ruled the interpretation of Mimì and Rodolfo of this opera. This is absolutely the best La Bohème recording available, although some may argue that sometimes Karajan's tempi may be a little bit slow. But Karajan shows his meticulosity in this recording by showing all the poetry and dramatical concept of this opera. The orchestra just sounds perfect, and the singers Freni, Pavarotti and Panerai are exactly Mimì, Rodolfo and Marcello. The combination between Freni and Pavarotti, the way they merge they voices together, is absolutely magic and essential for the results of this recording, because they have the adequate voices for both roles. Panerai sings the nicer Marcello of all, and Ghiaurov nails his Colline role, while Harwood delivers another great role as Musetta, despite her lack of perfect Italian, but with a lot of expressiveness.
Bottomline: this is the best La Bohème available, and it is a must in any opera discography. Thanks for reading!
P.S. If you find my review helpful, vote YES (It does not mean you agree. It just means you found it helpful). You can read all my other reviews if you wish to. I modestly write them to help people form an opinion about movies, music and books, but if nobody reads them (if you don't vote I do not know if you did) there is no point in writing them.
Rating: 
-
Expensive for an old recording
Considering the age of this ADD recording, the price should be lower. Twenty dollars sounds about fair. Awesome hearing the Berlin Philharmonic play Italian opera though!
Rating: -
A trip close to heaven
This is Pavarotti and Puccini as close as anyone has ever come to taking us to heaven on this earth. Nothing is perfect, but this is sublime.
Rating: -
A recording that will outlive us all of two of the most beautiful voices you will ever hear
I am writing this review a few days after the death of Luciano Pavarotti. Even if I do not know music, I like opera, and I love Puccini. This recording is one of the most beautiful I ever heard, and will make it clear, if ever there was any doubt, that we just lost one of the most outstanding artists of the 20th century. Forget about his incursions in pop music, forget about his late years marriage with a younger woman and forget about his frequent cancellations and all that. Just listen to "Che gelida manina" in this recording and weep... Mirella Freni is an amazing co-star, and her Mimi' is as superb as Pavarotti's Rodolfo. Everyone in this recording is superb. Here you will truly hear Pavarotti at his peak. Nothing less than magical. For another outstanding recording of the best Pavarotti, try the Turandot from the same label, directed by Mehta, and with an amazing Caballe' in the role of Liu'. Then, you will hear the most memorable "Nessun dorma" you will ever hear.
Thanks Mr Pavarotti for having made this world a better place.
Rating: 
-
Nice version of a classic opera
This is a worthwhile and strong version of a great opera, Puccini's "La Boheme." For the most part, the cast is nicely up to the task of making such a familiar opera interesting to attend to. Elizabeth Harwood is not up to the same standards as some of the other singers, such as the redoubtable Luciano Pavarotti, the wonderful soprano Mirella Freni, and the steady Rolando Panerai. Von Karajan does a fine job conducting his Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra.
Act I is exceedingly well done. It begins with the Bohemians fooling around. The singing is nicely in character, as Rodolfo, Marcello, Colline, and Schaunard cavort. There follows the trio of works, "Che gelida manina" (sung by Pavarotti as Rodolfo), "Si, mi chiamano Mimi" (sung by Mimi), and the passionate duet "O soave fanciulla" (Rodolfo and Mimi). The final high notes are normally sung offstage, but in this version, they seem a bit more muted than in some other versions. Nonetheless, Mimi and Rodolfo are glorious in this set of arias.
The second scene is at the Cafe Momus. It begins with a lively, energetic street scene. Well sung by the ensemble. The high point is "Quando men vo" (Musetta's waltz), sung in this instance by Harwood. Her singing is a bit harsh; the pace is a bit lugubrious. Not a high point. The ensemble singing after that among Mimi, Rodolfo, Marcello, Musetta, and the other Bohemians is nicely done.
Act III is most poignant. Marcello and Mimi share a scene, and their singing is well done; a bit later, Mimi hides while Rodolfo joins Marcello. Rodolfo sings of his fears of Mimi's precarious health; as he pours out his fears, of course, Mimi overhears. She and Rodolfo join in, to overuse the term, a poignant scene. Meanwhile Marcello and Musetta share insults, in a wickedly sung duet, over the latter's flirting with other men.
Finally, Act IV. This is one of opera's most touching moments. Suffice it to say that the Bohemians and Mimi sing well and bring this opera to a melodic and affecting conclusion.
This is one of the best versions of "La Boheme." Pavarotti is in his prime; Freni is still singing well (although I thought that her and Nicolai Gedda's version of this opera was even better). Well worth listening to. . . .
